Digestibility of amino acids, fiber, energy, and concentrations of digestible and metabolizable energy in conventional and extruded yellow dent corn, wheat, and sorghum fed to growing pigs

Extrusion of cereal grains may be used to improve nutrient digestibility in cereal grains because addition of heat and pressure in combination with addition of moisture during the extrusion may gelatinize the starch, which results in an increase in starch digestibility. It is also possible that AA and energy digestibility are increased by the extrusion, but data to verify this hypothesis have not been published. Therefore, the objective of these experiments was to test the hypothesis that the ileal digestibility of AA and starch and the apparent total tract digestibility (ATTD) of ADF, NDF, and GE as well as the concentrations of DE and ME in corn, wheat, and sorghum are increased by extrusion.

Experimental design

One source of yellow dent corn, one source of wheat, and one source of sorghum were ground and divided into 2 batches. One batch of each grain was used without further processing, whereas the other batches of the 3 grains were extruded. A total of 6 batches of grains were used (Table 1).

Exp. 1. Digestibility of CP, AA, and Starch

Seven diets were formulated. Three diets contained the non-extruded corn, wheat, or sorghum, and 3 additional diets contained the extruded grains. The last diet was an N-free diet that was used to determine the basal endogenous losses of AA from the pigs. Seven ileal cannulated pigs were used and allotted to a 7 × 7 Latin square design with 7 diets and 7 replicate pigs in each period. Therefore, there were 7 replicate pigs per treatment. Pigs were fed their diets in an amount equivalent to 3.4 times the maintenance energy requirement. An AA mixture was provided to all pigs during the initial 5 d of each period, but not during d 6 and 7. The initial 5 days of each period was considered the adaptation period to the diet, but ileal digesta were collected for 8 hours on days 6 and 7. The ileal digesta were analyzed for CP, AA, starch, and chromium to calculated the nutrient digestibility.

Exp. 2. Digestibility of NDF, ADF, and Energy

Six diets were formulated. Three diets contained the non-extruded corn, wheat, or sorghum, and 3 additional diets contained the extruded grain. Forty-eight growing barrows (initial BW = 15.1 ± 3.7 kg) were used. Pigs were fed for 5 days as adaptation period followed by 5 days of total, but separated, urine and fecal collection period. Samples were analyzed for GE, ADF and NDF. Based on the analyzed values, the ATTD of nutrients and the concentrations of DE and ME in each source of grains for extruded or non-extruded were then calculuated. Because all diets contained each source of grains as the sole source of energy, ADF, and NDF, the digestibility values for diets were also considered as values for ingredients

Results

Exp. 1. Digestibility of CP, AA, and Starch

There was no interaction between source of grains and form of ingredients on the AID of starch (Table 2). However, the extruded grains had greater (P < 0.001) AID of starch than non-extruded grains. The AID of CP and AA in wheat and sorghum was not affected by extrusion, but extruded corn had greater AID of CP and all AA except Lys and Pro than non-extruded corn (interaction, P < 0.05).

The SID of CP in corn was increased by extrusion, but SID of CP was not affected in wheat and sorghum (interaction, P < 0.01; Table 3). The SID of all AA was not affected by extrusion in wheat and sorghum, but extruded corn had greater SID of all AA except Lys and Pro compared with non-extruded corn (interaction, P < 0.05). Extrusion in all cereal grains increased (P < 0.05) the values for SID of all AA.

Exp. 2. Digestibility of NDF, ADF, and Energy

The ATTD of GE was increased by extrusion in corn and sorghum-based diets, but not in wheat-based diets (interaction, P < 0.001; Table 4). Values for ATTD of NDF were different among grains and extrusion reduced the ATTD of NDF but there was no interaction between the 2 factors. The ATTD of ADF in diets containing corn or wheat was reduced by extrusion, but the ATTD of ADF in sorghum was not affected by extrusion (interaction, P < 0.001).

Extrusion also increased the DE and ME in all sources of grains compared with non-extruded grains, but the difference was greater if pigs were fed sorghum compared with corn or wheat (interaction, P < 0.001; Table 5). The DE in non-extruded corn was greater (P < 0.05) than in non-extruded sorghum and the DE in extruded corn was greater (P < 0.05) than in extruded wheat. Likewise, the ME in non-extruded corn was greater (P < 0.05) than in non-extruded wheat and sorghum and the ME in extruded corn was greater (P < 0.05) than in extruded wheat.

Key points

  • Extrusion of corn, wheat, and sorghum increased the AID of starch compared with the AID of starch in non-extruded grains. Extrusion did not affect AID of CP and AA in wheat and sorghum, but extrusion of corn increased AID of CP and AA. 
  • The SID of CP in corn was increased by extrusion, but not in wheat or sorghum. The SID of all AA was increased if the cereal grains were extruded.
  • The ATTD of GE was greater in extruded corn and extruded sorghum than in non-extruded corn and sorghum.
  • The ATTD of ADF was reduced for extruded corn or wheat.  
  • Extrusion increased the DE and ME in corn, wheat, or sorghum.

 

Table 1. Chemical composition of non-extruded and extruded cereal grains1

Item, %

Corn

 

Wheat

 

Sorghum

Extruded

-

+

 

-

+

 

-

+

DM

88.69

91.08

 

88.62

90.67

 

88.23

91.07

GE

3,838

3,904

 

3,837

3,848

 

3,812

3,913

NDF

8.61

6.37

 

11.78

9.89

 

8.36

6.18

ADF

2.77

1.93

 

3.67

3.16

 

3.65

2.37

Starch

59.07

66.91

 

54.75

58.48

 

59.23

63.97

CP

7.80

7.60

 

13.31

13.44

 

9.49

8.27

Indispensable AA

             

  Arg

0.36

0.37

 

0.63

0.64

 

0.34

0.31

  His

0.21

0.21

 

0.30

0.30

 

0.20

0.18

  Ile

0.26

0.25

 

0.45

0.45

 

0.35

0.31

  Leu

0.86

0.84

 

0.85

0.85

 

1.20

1.00

  Lys

0.25

0.25

 

0.36

0.37

 

0.20

0.19

  Met

0.18

0.16

 

0.21

0.20

 

0.16

0.14

  Phe

0.35

0.37

 

0.60

0.60

 

0.45

0.42

  Thr

0.28

0.27

 

0.37

0.37

 

0.29

0.26

  Trp

0.06

0.06

 

0.16

0.16

 

0.10

0.09

  Val

0.36

0.35

 

0.56

0.55

 

0.45

0.40

  Total

3.16

3.12

 

4.48

4.49

 

3.74

3.30

Dispensable AA

             

  Ala

0.55

0.53

 

0.45

0.47

 

0.84

0.70

  Asp

0.53

0.52

 

0.65

0.67

 

0.60

0.53

  Cys

0.16

0.16

 

0.30

0.29

 

0.17

0.15

  Glu

1.38

1.33

 

3.68

3.63

 

1.91

1.61

  Gly

0.30

0.30

 

0.53

0.53

 

0.29

0.27

  Pro

0.61

0.61

 

1.31

1.30

 

0.79

0.65

  Ser

0.36

0.35

 

0.59

0.58

 

0.40

0.36

  Total

3.87

3.80

 

7.51

7.46

 

4.98

4.27

1All values except DM were adjusted to 88% DM.

 

Table 2. Apparent ileal digestibility of starch, CP, and AA in non-extruded and extruded cereal grains fed to growing pigs (Exp. 1)

Item, %

Corn

 

Wheat

 

Sorghum

SEM

P-value

Extruded

-

+

 

-

+

 

-

+

 

Grain

Extrusion

Grain × extrusion

Starch

90.7

99.2

 

94.1

98.8

 

93.2

99

1.3

0.419

< 0.001

0.277

CP

55.5c

75.8ab

 

76.5ab

80.9a

 

66.8b

69.7b

2.5

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.003

Indispensable AA

                     

  Arg

70.2c

84.3a

 

79.3abc

80.8ab

 

71.7bc

75.1abc

2.4

0.037

0.003

0.027

  His

72.7b

82.2a

 

81.0a

82.6a

 

69.4b

68.4b

1.6

< 0.001

0.013

0.006

  Ile

66.0c

80.7ab

 

79.2ab

83.7a

 

73.8b

75.6b

1.7

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.002

  Leu

77.7c

87.8a

 

81.0bc

84.9ab

 

80.9bc

81.9bc

1.3

0.454

< 0.001

0.005

  Lys

60.0

77.5

 

69.4

74.2

 

58.8

67.7

2.9

0.018

< 0.001

0.059

  Met

81.1c

89.7a

 

82.7bc

86.5ab

 

79.3c

81.5c

1.2

0.001

< 0.001

0.025

  Phe

76.8d

86.5ab

 

85.0abc

87.6a

 

80.4cd

81.3bcd

1.3

0.001

< 0.001

0.006

  Thr

49.8c

65.7ab

 

64.4ab

71.6a

 

58.3bc

59.4bc

2.7

0.001

0.001

0.035

  Trp

43.6c

60.6b

 

74.0a

78.2a

 

67.0ab

66.2ab

2.9

< 0.001

0.007

0.014

  Val

65.0c

78.5ab

 

76.1ab

80.2a

 

72.2bc

73.1ab

1.8

0.004

0.001

0.006

Total

69.8c

82.1a

 

78.0ab

81.7a

 

74.4bc

75.8abc

1.7

0.017

< 0.001

0.006

Dispensable AA

                     

  Ala

70.4cd

84.0a

 

67.5d

73.9bcd

 

77.8abc

79.1ab

1.9

0.001

< 0.001

0.009

  Asp

63.3b

78.2a

 

68.9ab

73.6a

 

69.6ab

71.9ab

2.1

0.958

< 0.001

0.013

  Cys

65.2b

76.0a

 

82.4a

83.5a

 

66.6b

64.5b

1.9

< 0.001

0.046

0.008

  Glu

76.6e

87.6bc

 

91.0ab

93.2a

 

80.1de

82.2cd

1.3

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.001

  Gly

28.9c

55.1ab

 

61.2a

64.0a

 

34.0bc

33.0bc

5.5

< 0.001

0.045

0.038

  Pro

28.4

71.8

 

81.8

86.8

 

52.0

53.3

12.0

0.012

0.088

0.138

  Ser

63.8d

77.1abc

 

78.8ab

81.6a

 

69.4cd

70.6bcd

1.9

< 0.001

0.001

0.007

Total

60.8c

79.5ab

 

83.0ab

85.8a

 

69.7bc

71.9bc

3.0

< 0.001

0.003

0.012

a-eWithin a row, means without a common superscript differ (P < 0.05).

 

Table 3. Standardized ileal digestibility of starch, CP, and AA in non-extruded and extruded cereal grains fed to growing pigs (Exp. 1)

Item, %

Corn

 

Wheat

 

Sorghum

SEM

P-value

Extruded

-

+

 

-

+

 

-

+

 

Grain

Extrusion

Grain × Extrusion

CP

75.7c

95.3a

 

88.2ab

92.4ab

 

83.0bc

88.2ab

2.5

0.111

< 0.001

0.007

Indispensable AA

                     

  Arg

83.5b

97.3a

 

87.2ab

88.4ab

 

86.1b

90.2ab

2.4

0.490

0.003

0.033

  His

79.8bc

89.2a

 

86.2ab

87.7a

 

76.9c

76.4c

1.6

< 0.001

0.011

0.008

  Ile

73.7c

88.4a

 

83.8ab

88.3a

 

79.5bc

82.1ab

1.7

0.006

< 0.001

0.003

  Leu

81.6c

91.8a

 

85.1bc

88.9ab

 

83.8bc

85.2bc

1.3

0.147

< 0.001

0.007

  Lys

67.7

85.1

 

75.0

79.5

 

69.1

77.8

2.9

0.370

< 0.001

0.057

  Met

84.1c

92.9a

 

85.5bc

89.3ab

 

82.7c

85.2bc

1.2

0.002

< 0.001

0.024

  Phe

80.6c

90.4a

 

87.4ab

90.0a

 

83.5bc

84.8abc

1.3

0.007

< 0.001

0.007

  Thr

67.2b

83.5a

 

77.9ab

84.8a

 

75.2ab

77.9ab

2.7

0.073

0.001

0.048

  Trp

61.9b

78.4a

 

81.0a

84.9a

 

77.8a

77.9a

2.9

0.001

0.008

0.023

  Val

73.8b

87.3a

 

81.8a

85.8a

 

79.2ab

80.9ab

1.8

0.098

< 0.001

0.008

Total

77.5c

89.9a

 

83.7abc

87.2ab

 

81.0bc

83.2abc

1.7

0.152

< 0.001

0.008

Dispensable AA

                     

  Ala

78.2b

91.7a

 

76.9b

82.9b

 

82.9b

85.1ab

1.9

0.022

< 0.001

0.015

  Asp

74.5c

89.3a

 

78.1bc

82.5ab

 

79.5bc

82.8abc

2.1

0.758

< 0.001

0.018

  Cys

76.1b

86.9a

 

88.5a

89.7a

 

77.4b

75.9b

1.9

< 0.001

0.037

0.010

  Glu

81.6b

92.7a

 

92.9a

95.2a

 

83.8b

86.5b

1.3

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.002

  Gly

81.1b

107.0a

 

91.5ab

93.9ab

 

89.3ab

90.0ab

5.5

0.719

0.039

0.048

  Pro

123.7

169.0

 

131.8

138.7

 

134.3

145.6

12.0

0.594

0.034

0.187

  Ser

77.7c

91.2a

 

87.7ab

90.4a

 

82.0bc

84.7abc

1.9

0.014

< 0.001

0.009

Total

86.4c

105.4a

 

96.8abc

99.6ab

 

90.2bc

95.2abc

3.0

0.206

0.001

0.019

a-cWithin a row, means without a common superscript differ (P < 0.05).

 

Table 4. Apparent total tract digestibility (ATTD) of nutrients in diets containing non-extruded or extruded cereal grains (Exp. 2)

Item, %

Corn

 

Wheat

 

Sorghum

SEM

P-value

Extruded

-

+

 

-

+

 

-

+

 

Grain

Extrusion

Grain × Extrusion

ATTD

                       

GE, %

88.2b

92.4a

 

86.9bc

88.3b

 

84.8c

91.5a

0.6

< 0.001

< 0.001

< 0.001

NDF, %

55.7

42.9

 

40.3

29.3

 

60.6

51.7

2.6

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.766

ADF, %

63.1cd

55.0e

 

80.2a

56.2de

 

64.6bc

71.2b

1.8

< 0.001

< 0.001

< 0.001

a-eWithin a row, means without a common superscript differ (P < 0.05).

 

Table 5. Concentrations of DE and ME in non-extruded and extruded cereal grains fed to pigs (Exp. 2)

Item, kcal/kg

Corn

 

Wheat

 

Sorghum

SEM

P-value

Extruded

-

+

 

-

+

 

-

+

 

Grain

Extrusion

Grain × Extrusion

As-fed basis

                     

  DE

3,405c

3,740a

 

3,338cd

3,499b

 

3,267d

3,674a

22

< 0.001

< 0.001

< 0.001

  ME

3,335b

3,626a

 

3,220c

3,365b

 

3,194c

3,557a

25

< 0.001

< 0.001

< 0.001

DM basis

                       

  DE

3,874b

4,098a

 

3,794b

3,848b

 

3,773b

4,002a

25

< 0.001

<0.001

0.001

  ME

3,794bc

3,972a

 

3,660d

3,701cd

 

3,689cd

3,875ab

28

<0.001

<0.001

0.018

a-dWithin a row, means without a common superscript differ (P < 0.05).

This report is based on unpublished research by Diego Rodriguez and Hans H. Stein.

Authors: 
Publication Type: